Aug 18

Trauma and Adult Learning

Trauma and Adult Learning. ERIC Digest.

by Kerka, Sandra

Adult learning can often be challenging, and traumatic events add extreme challenges to the learning process. The catalog of sources of trauma is sadly long: psychological or physical abuse, rape, war, forced relocation, diagnosis of a terminal illness, job loss, death or suicide of a loved one, divorce, robbery, natural disasters, and terrorism. Some view poverty, homelessness, and hate crimes as forms of systemic violence that cause trauma (Pearce 1999; Rosenwasser 2000). Much adult education literature focuses on the traumas of women who experience domestic violence or of refugees who come to literacy classes, yet adult learners in all settings and at all levels may have experienced traumatic events that have an impact on learning. Horsman (2000b) notes that trauma and violence are not equivalent, and the use of the terms implies a particular focus: with violence, the focus is on the individual and social agents of trauma and with trauma, on the response of the person experiencing it. This Digest focuses on the individual response to trauma, its effects on learning, and ways in which adult educators can respond.

Continue reading

Jul 20

A Well Deserved Poke At Adult Learning Principles and Styles

It is no secret that I believe adult learning principles and styles are essentially vague and useless in terms of instructing “adults” versus “non-adults” and that the work of many popular adult learning “experts” is terrible, and that includes Knowles. I’m not alone in that respect.

So I was browsing around and came across a well written article entitled How to Use Adult Learning Principles and Styles in Your Next Course, which I believe is typical of the thinking in that field. Despite the fact that it is well written, and clear, it’s nonsense, and it doesn’t even take much thought to realize it IS nonsense. Why many people can’t see the lack of clothing on this particular emperor is beyond me.

Continue reading

May 19

Andragogy Revisited: Theory for the 21st Century? #trdev

Myths and Realities no. 19 by Ralf St. Clair

Malcolm Knowles’ theory of andragogy is almost certainly the best known concept in adult education, and it often appears to gain uncritical acceptance based on name recognition rather than careful consideration of its propositions. Since Knowles introduced his theory in the mid-1960s, many concerns have been raised about how the claims of andragogy are grounded. Like any theoretical perspective, andragogy reflects both the context of its conception and the convictions of its creator. Illuminating this background can help educators to engage with andragogy more fully. This Myths and Realities examines the viability of andragogy in the 21st century by considering this background and asking which aspects of the theory are still useful more than 30 years later. Continue reading

May 27

When is a learner an adult?

Bob Gerulat wrote:

> Bacal wrote:
> >Insert humans instead of adults and it fits, so why make the distinction
> >about “adults”. Kids are pretty diverse. Kids have less experience
> >quantity wise which actually makes their experiences MORE powerful in
> >terms of how it affects learning.
>
> Gerulat Responds:
>As we can see from Mr. Bacal’s example, there are in fact
> differences in that kids have less experience and that there is a
> difference, in his opinion, in the power of these experiences.

Yes, absolutely, but the PRINCIPLE is exactly the same. Try this on.

Continue reading